Being accused of brandishing a weapon, assault with a deadly weapon (ADW), or making criminal threats can be overwhelming. These charges carry serious legal consequences, and understanding how they differ — as well as how they can overlap — is essential for protecting your rights.
In California, each offense is governed by its own laws, but real-world incidents often involve elements of more than one crime. This guide explains what each charge involves, how they can intersect, and what defenses may be available, providing clarity for anyone facing these serious allegations.
What is Brandishing?
Brandishing refers to displaying or drawing a deadly weapon in a threatening manner or using it in a confrontation without a lawful reason. The act itself, even without causing physical injury, can constitute a crime if it is intended to intimidate or provoke fear.
Key elements include drawing or exhibiting a weapon in the presence of another person, doing so in a threatening or aggressive way, and lacking a lawful justification such as self-defense. The term “deadly weapon” is interpreted broadly — objects not typically lethal may still qualify if they could cause serious harm under the circumstances.
Penalties for brandishing are generally classified as misdemeanors, with potential jail time of up to one year and fines. More serious cases, such as those involving injury, can escalate to felony charges.
Understanding Assault With a Deadly Weapon (ADW)
Assault with a deadly weapon involves attempting to apply force to another person or threatening imminent force while using an object capable of causing serious injury or death. Unlike brandishing, ADW focuses on the intent to harm or the attempt to harm someone, not merely the display of a weapon.
Even if no physical injury occurs, an act like swinging a bat, pointing a firearm, or throwing a heavy object with the intent to harm can meet the criteria for ADW. The law is flexible in defining what constitutes a deadly weapon based on the circumstances of the incident.
ADW can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony. Misdemeanors may carry up to one year in county jail, while felony convictions can result in several years of state prison, depending on the weapon used and the severity of the incident.
What Counts as Criminal Threats?
Criminal threats involve threatening to cause death or serious injury to someone else, even if the threat is verbal, written, or electronic. The law focuses on the reasonable fear experienced by the intended victim, not necessarily whether the defendant could actually carry out the threat.
A conviction requires proof that the threat was credible and caused the victim to fear for their safety. Criminal threat charges can also be classified as misdemeanors or felonies, with potential jail or prison time depending on the specifics of the case.
How These Crimes Can Overlap: An Example
To illustrate how brandishing, ADW, and criminal threats can occur in a single incident, consider the following scenario:
Two people get into a heated argument outside a bar. During the dispute, one person pulls out a pocketknife and waves it toward the other while shouting, “I’m going to hurt you!” The argument escalates, and the individual swings the knife at the other person but misses.
In this situation:
-
Brandishing applies because the knife was drawn and exhibited in a threatening manner.
-
Criminal threats apply because the verbal threat caused the other person to reasonably fear for their safety.
-
Assault with a deadly weapon (ADW) applies because the person attempted to strike the other with the knife, even though no physical contact occurred.
This example shows how a single confrontation can lead to multiple charges, emphasizing the importance of understanding the law and seeking skilled legal guidance immediately.
Common Defenses
Several defenses may be available depending on the circumstances:
-
Self-Defense or Defense of Others: If a person reasonably believed they or someone else was in imminent danger, they may have a legal justification for their actions.
-
Lack of Threatening Behavior or Intent: The act may not have been intended to intimidate or cause harm.
-
Insufficient Evidence: If the prosecution cannot prove that the defendant used or attempted to use a weapon, or that the victim reasonably feared for their safety, charges may be reduced or dismissed.
-
Improper Charging: Sometimes prosecutors overcharge to create leverage for a plea deal. A skilled defense attorney can challenge these charges.
Each defense requires careful review of the facts, the behavior involved, and the context in which the incident occurred.
Why Understanding These Differences Matters
Knowing the distinctions between brandishing, ADW, and criminal threats is crucial for developing a strong defense. It helps evaluate the strength of the prosecution’s case, plan a legal strategy, and provide realistic guidance about outcomes.
This knowledge is also critical for anyone facing these charges, as even a misdemeanor conviction can have long-term effects on employment, gun rights, and other aspects of life.
Conclusion
Brandishing, assault with a deadly weapon, and criminal threats are distinct but interconnected offenses under California law. While brandishing focuses on the display of a weapon, ADW concerns the attempt or threat of force, and criminal threats target verbal or written threats that create fear.
Incidents often involve elements of more than one offense, which is why experienced legal representation is essential. The right defense can lead to reduced charges, dismissal, or more favorable outcomes.
If you or a loved one is facing any of these charges in Southern California, Southwest Legal is here to help. Our experienced criminal defense attorneys understand the complexities of California law and are committed to protecting your rights every step of the way. Don’t wait — the sooner you consult with a qualified defense attorney, the stronger your defense can be. Call us now to schedule your free, confidential consultation and safeguard your future.
